Start free trial

Retention of title and the PPSR: protecting your stock before a customer fails

A retention of title clause only protects your goods in a customer's liquidation if it is registered on the PPSR, on time. What to register, when, and what it costs.

Insolvency Alerts5 min read

Most trade terms say something like “title in the goods does not pass until we are paid in full”. Suppliers rely on it, believing that if a customer fails, they can take their unpaid goods back. Under Australian law, that clause alone usually isn’t enough.

The short version

  • Retention of title is a security interest under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009.
  • Unregistered, it usually fails when it matters most. If your customer goes into liquidation or administration, your interest vests in them and you become an unsecured creditor.
  • Registering on the PPSR costs from $6, but it has to be done on time, and before delivery for stock your customer will resell.

This is general information, not legal advice. The PPS rules are technical, and a mistake in a registration can make it ineffective, so have your terms and registrations checked by a lawyer.

Why the clause alone isn’t enough

The Personal Property Securities Act treats an agreement to sell subject to retention of title as a security interest (s 12(2)(d)). Because it secures the price of the goods themselves, it is also a purchase money security interest, or PMSI (s 14).

A security interest has to be perfected, which for a supplier almost always means registered on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR). If it isn’t perfected when the customer goes into liquidation, administration or restructuring, it vests in the customer immediately before that happens (s 267). The goods join the pool available to all creditors, and you stand in line with everyone else.

When to register

Timing decides whether your registration works. Two sets of rules apply.

For priority over other secured creditors (PMSI super-priority, s 62)

Your goods are… Register…
Inventory: stock your customer holds to sell or lease Before the customer takes possession, so before delivery
Other goods, such as equipment for the customer’s own use Within 15 business days after the customer takes possession

The registration must also say it is a PMSI. Ticking the PMSI box when the interest isn’t one can make the whole registration ineffective, so get this right.

To survive the customer’s insolvency (Corporations Act s 588FL)

Even a registered interest can vest in the company if it was registered late. It is safe if it was registered within 20 business days of the security agreement coming into force, or more than 6 months before the customer’s liquidation, administration or restructuring began.

Business days leave out weekends and public holidays, so 15 business days is at least three weeks, and longer over Easter or Christmas. If your system works these deadlines out from delivery or agreement dates, a business-day API such as Finance Calendar API can do the counting for you.

In practice: register when you open the account, before the first delivery.

What it costs

Registrations are made online on the PPSR, run by the Australian Financial Security Authority. Current fees:

Registration length Fee
7 years or less $6
Over 7 years, up to 25 years $25
No end date $115
A search of the register $2

Registrations over consumer property and serial-numbered goods are limited to 7 years.

Other arrangements that are also security interests

If you hire, lease or consign goods rather than sell them, the Act may still treat the arrangement as a security interest that needs registering:

  • PPS lease (s 13). A lease or hire, by someone regularly in that business, for more than 2 years, including terms that can run past 2 years through renewals. This threshold applies to leases entered into from 20 May 2017.
  • Commercial consignment (s 10). You deliver goods to a business that deals in them, for it to sell, and keep an interest in them until they are sold.

Serial-numbered goods

For some classes of goods, including motor vehicles and watercraft, the registration can describe the goods by serial number. For consumer property that is required. For commercial property it is optional, but leaving it out can cost you your interest if the goods are sold on.

A checklist for your credit process

  1. Check your terms include a retention of title clause that suits your business, reviewed by a lawyer.
  2. Register on the PPSR when you open each account, before the first delivery.
  3. Mark it as a PMSI where it is one, and choose the right collateral class.
  4. Keep registrations current, and diarise renewals before they lapse.
  5. Watch your customers. Registration protects the goods; knowing early that a customer has failed gives you the best chance to identify and recover them. You can check any company for free.

That last step is where Insolvency Alerts helps. It watches ASIC’s notices for every customer on your list and tells you as soon as one enters liquidation, administration or restructuring, while the goods are still there to find. Our post on what happens when a customer goes into administration covers the rest of the first week.

Questions

Is a retention of title clause enough on its own?

No. Under the Personal Property Securities Act, retention of title is a security interest. If it isn't registered on the PPSR, it generally vests in the customer when they go into liquidation or administration, and you are left as an unsecured creditor.

When do I have to register?

For goods your customer holds as inventory, before they take possession. For other goods, within 15 business days after they take possession. Registering within 20 business days of the agreement also avoids the Corporations Act vesting rule.

How much does a PPSR registration cost?

Currently $6 for a registration of 7 years or less, $25 for up to 25 years, and $115 for no end date, when made online.

Do I need a new registration for every order?

Usually not. Many suppliers make one registration per customer and collateral class that covers repeat supplies under the same terms. Get advice on how to set yours up.